top of page

Sternberg Creates Marlene Dietrich's Persona

Nov 6
3 min read

Updated: Nov 10


Searching for an untamed, raw sensuality, Sternberg

discovered her in Berlin. He was captivated by the cool,

disdainful look she directed at her audience. 

In 1929, Joseph von Sternberg was invited to Germany to direct a film starring Emil Jannings. The two had previously worked together on The Last Command (1928). Although they reportedly clashed during production, Jannings, admiring his cinematic skill, wanted Sternberg to direct the new film. UFA’s head of production, Erich Pommer, negotiated Sternberg’s contract in the United States.

The project was conceived as a major, multilingual production. The story required an actress to play Lola Lola, the sensual performer whose earthbound allure ensnares a respectable university professor. UFA had already begun considering candidates for the role. Brigitte Helm, best known for playing the roles of Maria and her mechanical double in

Fritz Lang’s Metropolis (1927) was one of the potential candidates for the role of Lola Lola.

Sternberg found that insolent quality in Dietrich to give Lola Lola that destructive feature of femme fatale.

Sternberg felt Helm’s elegance and stylized screen presence were not right for the character’s earthly sensuality. She was also involved in another project and reportedly reluctant to play a cabaret singer. Another possibility was Lucie Mannheim. By contrast, she was primarily a stage actress. Sternberg considered her style too conventional for the role and felt she lacked the erotic appeal he believed Lola Lola required. He did not want someone who could merely perform seduction. He wanted a woman whose physical presence, her response to the light, and her manner and voice expressed an effortless, almost unconscious power over men.

Sternberg used the off-screen tension to develop the on-screen relationship.


Until he saw Marlene Dietrich on stage in the revue Zwei Krawatten ("Two Ties"), he observed her position sitting on a chair with cold, indifferent poise, looking at the audience with contempt. He felt her insolent quality was precisely what Helm and Mannheim lacked, so he rejected UFA's established stars and risked the production on an unproven Dietrich. Jannings and the front office, however, remained strongly opposed to the idea. Janning didn't want to share the screen with a newcomer and was worried she would try to steal his scenes.

Despite Brigitte Helm's popularity after her excellent performance in Metropolis, Sternberg felt her elegance would work against her for The Blue Angel.

Janning's resentment toward the unknown actress was apparent early on. He saw her as a minor player and did not try to hide his contempt for her. This changed the behind-the-scenes dynamic between the two lead actors, bringing about intense professional jealousy and rivalry. Sternberg used the off-screen tension to develop the on-screen relationship (1). Janning had recently returned from his successful trip to Hollywood, where he played lead roles in The Way of All Flesh (1927), directed by Victor Fleming, and The Last Command (1928). The Academy Awards in its first year gave the Oscar for Best Actor to Jennings for both films.



Armed with a raw, unrestrained allure, she ignored social class boundaries—aware that masculine desire remains the same across classes. 
Armed with a raw, unrestrained allure, she ignored social class boundaries—aware that masculine desire remains the same across classes. 

He believed his stature as a major international star would give him sufficient influence to choose his leading actress. While this assumption might have been justified under other circumstances, he underestimated Sternberg's presence: a prominent director known for Underworld (1927) and The Docks of New York (1928) and for directing one of the films that helped secure Jannings’s reputation. Sternberg also was known for his authoritarian behavior on set; he did not respect the actors as artists (2). He mostly saw them as tools for his personal expression. Armed with a raw, unrestrained allure, she ignored social class boundaries—aware that masculine desire remains the same across classes. 

To be continued


Notes

  1. Interestingly, during the making of Pandora's Box (1929), Fritz Kortner, the male lead and a prominent German actor, felt similarly toward Louise Brooks. Unlike Dietrich, she was not a newcomer to cinema; however, her career up to that point was in the US, which probably made Kortner look at her with contempt. Pabst brought this off-camera tension to the screen, too.

  2. Sternberg was not the only director who discounted the player's contribution to the movie. When he had just arrived in Hollywood, Hitchcock said, “Actors are cattle.” Several years later, he decided to refine his earlier statement to "I have been misquoted. I never said actors are cattle; I said they should be treated like cattle."



Comments


  • Facebook

Website content © 2025 by Rayford Publishing.

Nothing may be reproduced without permission.

​

​

​

Site made by Domini Dragoone / Sage Folio Creative

​

bottom of page